Announcement

Collapse

HUG - here for all audio enthusiasts

Since its inception ten years ago, the Harbeth User Group's ambition has been to create a lasting knowledge archive. Knowledge is based on facts and observations. Knowledge is timeless. Knowledge is human independent and replicatable. However, we live in new world where thanks to social media, 'facts' have become flexible and personal. HUG operates in that real world.

HUG has two approaches to contributor's Posts. If you have, like us, a scientific mind and are curious about how the ear works, how it can lead us to make the right - and wrong - decisions, and about the technical ins and outs of audio equipment, how it's designed and what choices the designer makes, then the factual area of HUG is for you. The objective methods of comparing audio equipment under controlled conditions has been thoroughly examined here on HUG and elsewhere and can be easily understood and tried with negligible technical knowledge.

Alternatively, if you just like chatting about audio and subjectivity rules for you, then the Subjective Soundings sub-forum is you. If upon examination we think that Posts are better suited to one sub-forum than than the other, they will be redirected during Moderation, which is applied throughout the site.

Questions and Posts about, for example, 'does amplifier A sounds better than amplifier B' or 'which speaker stands or cables are best' are suitable for the Subjective Soundings area.

The Moderators' decision is final in all matters regarding what appears here. That said, very few Posts are rejected. HUG Moderation individually spell and layout checks Posts for clarity but due to the workload, Posts in the Subjective Soundings area, from Oct. 2016 will not be. We regret that but we are unable to accept Posts that present what we consider to be free advertising for products that Harbeth does not make.

That's it! Enjoy!

{Updated Nov. 2016A}
See more
See less

Harbeth P3ESR or C7ES3

Collapse
X
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Harbeth P3ESR or C7ES3

    First of all my name is Igor, I'm from Macedonia and I'd like to say Hi to everyone on the HUG and say that this is the first time to see such a great community and honest answers from the manufacturer(s) regarding their products.

    Now my problem,

    I've been searching high quallity speakers for my small room (3.5 x 3.5 meters) and nothing in my price range, I dont know how to explain this sounded "right" to me.That was until one day I had the chance to listen the P3ESR at a friends house and this was a magical moment, I forget everything and just enjoyed the music.

    From that moment I knew Harbeth is the way to go for me, but here is the problem.In my country there is no dealer and I'll have to travel 400-500km to another country where the nearest dealer is.

    I have the budget for the P3ESR and could possibly strech it for the C7ES3 (that means 2-3 months from now I'll have the money to buy the C7ES3) if this is the better choice.I dont mind waiting since this purchase will be for a long time enjoyment (7-8 years minimum).

    I should add that my music preferences are great vocals (most important), jazz, acoustics, blues, some times soft rock and instrumental.

    I listen at moderate levels but like to crank up the sound some times.

    Finally the room as I mentioned above is on the small side 3.5m x 3.5m but there is a lott of stuff bed, sofa, wardrobe, chairs, and behind the listening position there is a heavy curtain from the floor to the roof of my room which strech for nearly 2.5meters.

    I should add that I cant listen to the c7es3, I got lucky that I had the oportunity to listen the P3ESR and I fell in love with it :).

    So whats your opinions on these 2 speakers with all things considered from above?

    Oh, I almost forgot, Mr.Shaw you really make one of the best sounding speakers and also verry reasonable priced (well they are expensive but for what you pay you get a lott more).

    Greatings

  • #2
    P3ESR or C7ES3?

    Welcome. Can't lose with either speaker obviously. I am in a similar sized room, with similar musical preferences as yours and I find the P3ESR's to be more than enough. Surprising bass and a rich full sound. I may have bought the 7's if I had the money but I don't feel that I am lacking anything at all. They are the most wonderful speakers I've ever owned.

    One of my favorite coworkers, Vesna Cogurik is from Macedonia. She is teaching us much about your country.

    Comment


    • #3
      Away from walls?

      Igor,

      If bass is important and you can be 1 1/2-2 meters away from the speakers go with the Compact 7ES3. Otherwise, the P3ESR would be the better choice.

      Comment


      • #4
        Neighbours?

        Hello Igor. Welcome to HUG.

        Do you have neighbours the other side of any wall? This would push my decision towards P3ESRs. I have neighbours the other side of a thin wall and enjoy music all the more for the knowledge that my little speakers do not disturb them. Hence my decision to go with P3ES2s (predecessor to P3ESRs).

        I'm delighted with the ES2s. I hear the ESRs are better still.

        Best regards, Ben
        Ben from UK. Harbeth Super HL5 owner.

        Comment


        • #5
          Thanks - P3ESR best choice?

          Well thanks for all of your suggestions,

          Art K:

          It's good to hear that the P3ESR is a very capable little speaker, and I must say you surprised me that you know about my country, most of the people in the forums have never heard the name.

          Drdennis:

          Bass is not important at all, all I need is a tight and controled, well defined.My listening position is 1.5meters from the speakers since I sit on the sofa and very often I sit in front of my PC doing some work while listening to music.

          I dont have neighbours since I live in a house and loud music is not a problem, actually my preference is moderate levels.

          From your opinions I see that for my room and the things I need maybe the P3ESR is the best choice, since none of you said that the sound quality of the C7 is better, only that it's better for a bigger room or maybe louder music?

          Is this correct or am I missing something here?

          thanks

          Comment


          • #6
            The P3ESR is truly a gem to last a lifetime

            Igor, for your perfect square room I would think the P3ESR is a more suitable candidate than the C7ES3. Easier to place in the room with less problems.

            Another point to note is some SHL5 and 40.1 users bought the P3ESR to be used in a 2nd system. A friend of mine who is a 40.1 user got the P3ESR for his bedroom system. If I consider setting up a 2nd system (in due time) it would be the P3ESR. The P3ESR is truly a gem that will last you a life time.

            Comment


            • #7
              Thanks for the info ryder,

              I'm starting to develop the same opinion as yours about the P3ESR that this could really be a little gem, after all Mr.Shaw himself said that this is a product of 4 years of hard work and maybe will be wiser to add the money intended for the C7ES3 in the budget for a good stereo amp.

              Also I can get the P3ESR for a very good price since I'll buy from another country and will get Tax Return and at top of everything they will be Rosewood SE.I know that Special Edition doesn't mean better product but somehow it gives a little better feeling in the mind :) especially for the same price.

              Another thing, how would you compare the metal tweeter on the C7ES3 or even P3ESR with let's say the Excel in the M30 is it refined enough? There is a little option even if I go for the C7ES3 that for very little money to get the M30 (overal how is the M30 compared to the others) and thats why I'm asking this last question because maybe in the near future (3-4 years) I'll have a bigger place for my audio enjoyment.

              Greetings

              {Moderator's comment: General point - buying outside your country ...... Buying from another country (unless there is definitely no Harbeth official importer in your county) than yours is both against the spirit of the Harbeth organisation and voids your Warranty. If you do not have an official Harbeth importer in your country and you do buy from an adjacent country please get a written document that says the seller will personally promise to give you after care warranty. Normally, out-of-territory sales result in a cancelled Warranty.}

              Comment


              • #8
                P3ESR - superb throughout the range

                Igor:

                After going through the same mental merry-go-round as you, I've decided to stick with my P3ESRs for now. The primary reason being that I live in a condominium building and I'm concerned about a speaker that might generate too much bass, which travels through walls much more easily than higher frequencies. The sound quality is superb throughout the Harbeth range so I wouldn't be too concerned about significant differences between models, aside from bass and overall loudness capability. But in a room as small as yours (same as my listening room), I don't think you will have any trouble filling it with the P3ESR.

                For the same reason, I wouldn't focus too much on the M30 tweeter. Yes, it's excellent, but you don't listen to just a tweeter, you listen to an entire speaker. I've compared the M30 and the Compact 7 ES-3 and there are aspects of both that I like, without a clear favourite between the two. But unless you decide that the P3ESR is not enough, that's not a decision you need to worry about.

                Comment


                • #9
                  Macedonia - no importer

                  The thing is that there is no official importer in Macedonia for Harbeth, I'll be alot more happy if I can go and audition the speakers here to buy them but since there isn't I have to go in another country or buy second hand but then again these are very rare speakers and I like to buy knew stuff and support the manufacturer.

                  Thanks for the advice on the warranty I'll sort that with them when the day comes for the purchase.

                  Originally posted by igor_xxx View Post

                  {Moderator's comment: General point - buying outside your country ...... Buying from another country (unless there is definitely no Harbeth official importer in your county) than yours is both against the spirit of the Harbeth organisation and voids your Warranty. If you do not have an official Harbeth importer in your country and you do buy from an adjacent country please get a written document that says the seller will personally promise to give you after care warranty. Normally, out-of-territory sales result in a cancelled Warranty.}
                  I see your point EricW and I think thats the right way to go with the P3ESR.I really dont need high SPL (well some times most when I watch movies but thats not that important).I ask these questions because I dont know if the sound is a lot different between differrent models or all I need to know is that Radial2+Harbeth is a win-win situation and all that is there is to choose the size of the speaker for the room.In my case P3ESR.

                  I really start to think this sholud be my choice.
                  Last edited by igor_xxx; 18-12-2010, 02:06 PM. Reason: Error

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    I am another satisfied P3ESR user!

                    Hello Igor, I'm another satisfied P3ESR owner and would fully recommend it. It is a very good loudspeaker, even for medium-sized rooms.

                    Just curious - what amplifier are you using?

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      P3ESR big sound

                      thanks for the info singslingr, I must be honest and say that the first time when I saw the P3ESR I didn't think at all that this speaker can manage to give big sound and scale without sounding like everything is compressed.

                      this is my first upgrade, the amp and source will follow soon, for now I have the Panasonic SA-HE75 Avr but I want good stereo amp.The listening was with a Naim 5i and I liked it a lott.

                      I really wish I could listen the M30 and C7 and form an opinion about them since the purchase will be blind, I'll have to order them unheard.

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        P3esr

                        Originally posted by igor_xxx View Post
                        thanks for the info singslingr, I must be honest and say that the first time when I saw the P3ESR I didn't think at all that this speaker can manage to give big sound and scale without sounding like everything is compressed.

                        this is my first upgrade, the amp and source will follow soon, for now I have the Panasonic SA-HE75 Avr but I want good stereo amp.The listening was with a Naim 5i and I liked it a lott.

                        I really wish I could listen the M30 and C7 and form an opinion about them since the purchase will be blind, I'll have to order them unheard.
                        Hello Igor,

                        Sorry I'm not familiar with your amp but I use the P3ESR mainly with Naim amplifiers so I can highly recommend the Harbeth-Naim combination - it's very musical and sounds good even at low volumes. The Nait 5i is very highly rated within the Naim range so it would be a good match.

                        Also, just a gentle reminder to get a decent set of stands for the Harbeths as they benefit from having good support.

                        Good luck and by the way - welcome to HUG!

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          All great - whichever

                          Igor,
                          They are all great speakers and you won't go wrong whichever you choose.

                          As for the amp - a Nait will sound far better than the AV jobbie and they go well with Harbeth speakers.

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Buy without listening!

                            One more thing, Igor

                            Don't worry about going in blind. I bought both my pairs of Harbeth speakers (Compact 7 ES 2 and Monitor 30) without having heard them prior to purchase, and was absolutely delighted with them.

                            Enjoy, welcome to the HUG!

                            Bob LaBarca
                            State College, PA
                            USA

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Great advice

                              Thanks for all the great info, this really is a great place to get some good advice.

                              I

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X