Announcement

Collapse

HUG - here for all audio enthusiasts

Since its inception ten years ago, the Harbeth User Group's ambition has been to create a lasting knowledge archive. Knowledge is based on facts and observations. Knowledge is timeless. Knowledge is human independent and replicatable. However, we live in new world where thanks to social media, 'facts' have become flexible and personal. HUG operates in that real world.

HUG has two approaches to contributor's Posts. If you have, like us, a scientific mind and are curious about how the ear works, how it can lead us to make the right - and wrong - decisions, and about the technical ins and outs of audio equipment, how it's designed and what choices the designer makes, then the factual area of HUG is for you. The objective methods of comparing audio equipment under controlled conditions has been thoroughly examined here on HUG and elsewhere and can be easily understood and tried with negligible technical knowledge.

Alternatively, if you just like chatting about audio and subjectivity rules for you, then the Subjective Soundings sub-forum is you. If upon examination we think that Posts are better suited to one sub-forum than than the other, they will be redirected during Moderation, which is applied throughout the site.

Questions and Posts about, for example, 'does amplifier A sounds better than amplifier B' or 'which speaker stands or cables are best' are suitable for the Subjective Soundings area.

The Moderators' decision is final in all matters regarding what appears here. That said, very few Posts are rejected. HUG Moderation individually spell and layout checks Posts for clarity but due to the workload, Posts in the Subjective Soundings area, from Oct. 2016 will not be. We regret that but we are unable to accept Posts that present what we consider to be free advertising for products that Harbeth does not make.

That's it! Enjoy!

{Updated Nov. 2016A}
See more
See less

Another idea for a new Harbeth speaker

Collapse
X
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Another idea for a new Harbeth speaker

    While enjoying the sound of my new P3ESRs very much, I couldn't help wondering what the following imaginary speaker might sound like, built with all-Radial drivers of course. But before I explain what "the following" is, let me (at the risk of being long-winded) explain what gives rise to this idea.

    1. I recently purchased a new pair of computer speakers called iNNosound Piccolos, made by a small company in South Korea. They look like another other little speakers made for that application, but they're not: they key difference is that they have not only internal amplification but also an internal DAC, and one 2.5" (!) Peerless driver per side. They sound amazingly good (for what they are) and voices in particular come through very clearly and naturally. They remind of how a simple single-driver setup as found in say a car radio or a TV or a table radio (and the Piccolos are quite a bit better than that) can sometimes sound better than a typical "hi-fi" speaker. Despite lacking loudness and extension, they can sound more real, somehow (though not more real than a Harbeth, of course!). A review of the Piccolo - which is quite accurate - can be found on the 6 Moons website.

    2. Another interesting speaker than I've seem reviewed (but have not heard) is made by an Austrian company called WLM. What's interesting about them is that they have a couple of models that use a cone tweeter with a 2.5" diameter, crossed over at a very low frequency (1200 hz, I think).

    3. I seem to recall reading a post by Alan about running the 8" Radial driver full-range, and being surprised by how good it sounded.

    So, putting all of the above together, I can't help but wonder how a Harbeth with, say, an 8" Radial woofer and a 2.5" Radial cone midrange/tweeter might sound. I expect that dispersion in the high frequencies might suffer a bit compared to a conventional dome tweeter, but might there be other advantages to offset this? Also, if this were a feasible concept, it would truly be an "all-Harbeth" product, which I'm sure many loyal fans of the brand would support.

  • #2
    Re: Another idea for a new Harbeth speaker

    Okay, let me simplify the question:

    Is a Harbeth-built Radial cone tweeter a feasible proposition, as an alternative to an externally-sourced dome tweeter? What would be the pluses and minuses?

    The cone tweeter is not completely dead so I'm presuming there are at least some potential advantages, or people would stop making them entirely. Right or wrong?

    Comment


    • #3
      Re: Another idea for a new Harbeth speaker

      All useful feedback.

      Yes, I have been thinking about making the RADIAL? driver in a variety of sizes and agree with you that it could be of considerable benefit in bringing clarity to a really small speaker. In a shopping mall I passed a manufacturer's franchise store demonstrating their brands miniature surround speaker systems, used for home theatre. I was impressed by the immersive (it seems that's not a real word) sound experience with noises, explosions and FX all around from the small speakers. Unfortunately, when the dialogue started, the limitations of the speakers was evident: there was no clarity at all in the front, dialogue channel which was very muffled. Disappointing.
      Alan A. Shaw
      Designer, owner
      Harbeth Audio UK

      Comment


      • #4
        Re: Another idea for a new Harbeth speaker

        I have been looking up and down in vain for a pair of decent small speakers for my computer desk. If you can make an active miniature Harbeth that can be used as a computer speaker I think there will be a market for it. If you can do your crossover magic to make a matching subwoofer to extend the bass that would be doubly nice.

        The surround sound is engaging only during the span of the movie. But there is hardly any movies that one wants to watch more than once, except for the musicals. I find that for musicals and music performances the surround speakers are strictly optional. I have not come across any music DVD that makes effective use of the surround speakers yet. There is really nothing much happening at the back with the performers playing at the front.

        I don't watch that many movies, so I have more or less given up on the surround speakers for now. My take is that stereo sound will still be the norm for a long time to come.

        Cheers,
        Yee

        Comment


        • #5
          Re: Another idea for a new Harbeth speaker

          Originally posted by yeecn View Post
          I have been looking up and down in vain for a pair of decent small speakers for my computer desk.

          Cheers,
          Yee
          Yee, seriously, consider trying the Piccolos. They're amazing. Until Harbeth makes a computer speaker, I really think this is the best you can do, unless you get something quite a bit bigger like an Adam or a Dynaudio - and even they don't have the built-in DAC.

          Comment


          • #6
            Re: Another idea for a new Harbeth speaker

            Thanks for the info Eric, I am surprised to see Dynaudio foraying into desktop speakers space. I think it is an indication that the high-end is finally noticing this market sector. I spend more time at my work table than the living room. I have been wondering why this market sector has been so neglected by the big boys.

            I just checked, Dynaudio offer is selling in Malaysia for USD 2500. Phew... I can buy a P3ESR with a decent amplifier for that money. I don't think I can find the other brands you mentioned. The market here is flooded with sub USB 60 systems, but there is almost nothing beyond that price range. Saying that they sounded bad is an understatement.

            I don't think DAC is important. I will be running it off my computer mostly, and most media player already comes with a DAC.

            I am also thinking of setting up a decent sound system in my bed room. A pair of small active speakers with a media player (like logitech squeezebox) is my only chance of getting past the wife-acceptance barrier. Frankly - I would not put an imposing pile of electronics and a mess of tangling wires in my bedroom myself.

            Alan - any chance of releasing an active P3ESR? Or something even smaller?

            Comment


            • #7
              Re: Another idea for a new Harbeth speaker

              I would guess that a pair of active P3ESR would sell for around ?2000 and I would be surprised if there is much of a market for such a speaker.

              Don't shout at me but I see Harbeth as a high quality speaker manufacturer and the market for active computer speakers is mainly price and style led with sound quality very much a secondary consideration. All the computer installations I have seen employ the likes of Bose or JBL if they are 'serious' about the sound and these generally sell for a ?100 or so.I don't see Harbeth wanting to compete in this market.

              Surely, if you really are enthusiastic about computer audio, you would employ a DAC and feed it into your Hi-Fi system where the Harbeth's reside !!!

              Comment


              • #8
                Re: Another idea for a new Harbeth speaker

                I don't know about you guys, but life style is very important for me.

                I have a dilemma here. I had wanted to get a decent sound system for my bed room for months. We have been using one of those USD 100 mini-combo system. The whole setup sites nicely on a small bench top inconspicuously.

                Wife acceptance is the deciding factor in my consideration. I was very tempted to buy a pair of P3ESR, which would just be barely acceptable, but then there is no way my wife would agree to the electronics and the wires. So my options are down to:
                1) Stick to my el-cheapo japanese mini-compo system,
                2) Get a pair of small active speakers with a tiny media player (for example logitech squeezebox touch).

                The same considerations goes with my study/work room.

                For me good music should be integral to our living space, much like good decorations and lighting. It is about harmony, sharing and relationship. My household cut down on TV dramatically since I setup the Hifi system. That to me is already a great improvements in our qualify of life. For that matter I would never set up a dedicated listening room for myself.

                Comment


                • #9
                  Re: Another idea for a new Harbeth speaker

                  Alan, what you think about the sound qualities of an ACTIVE speaker in the size of C7/HL5, ported or sealed, fited with switches in the active crossover to accomodate the bas and treble room response. Can bring such version SIGNIFICANT improovement in sound against the passive version?

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Re: Another idea for a new Harbeth speaker

                    Originally posted by hifi_dave View Post
                    I would guess that a pair of active P3ESR would sell for around ?2000 and I would be surprised if there is much of a market for such a speaker.

                    Don't shout at me but I see Harbeth as a high quality speaker manufacturer and the market for active computer speakers is mainly price and style led with sound quality very much a secondary consideration. All the computer installations I have seen employ the likes of Bose or JBL if they are 'serious' about the sound and these generally sell for a ?100 or so.I don't see Harbeth wanting to compete in this market.

                    Surely, if you really are enthusiastic about computer audio, you would employ a DAC and feed it into your Hi-Fi system where the Harbeth's reside !!!

                    I have to offer a soft-spoken alternative view here. I have a bachelor friend who has far more invested in a high-end system than I ever could, as a married-with-young adults-still-at-home. He had, till recently, the works: hi-end TT, electrostats bigger than a door, thousands of records lining the house, ARC electronics, etc. Does more and more of his listening via the internet through his desktop, and a DAC. He is very interested in high quality active desktop monitors; has some nice ones he shows with pride. I read more and more about this as the coming thing; my 25 year-old has set up something similar with his PC, appropriating my tubed head-phone amp as part of the setup.

                    I can see a future for Harbeth in raising the bar for this growing segment.

                    -paul-

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Re: Another idea for a new Harbeth speaker

                      Originally posted by Vlado View Post
                      Alan, what you think about the sound qualities of an ACTIVE speaker in the size of C7/HL5, ported or sealed, fited with switches in the active crossover to accomodate the bas and treble room response. Can bring such version SIGNIFICANT improovement in sound against the passive version?
                      Not just active, but with internal DAC would be my vote. No question in my mind that is the way of the future. One UK manufacturer has already gone in this direction (AVI).

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Re: Another idea for a new Harbeth speaker

                        Originally posted by EricW View Post
                        Not just active, but with internal DAC would be my vote.
                        I'm not mentioned intentionaly the DAC, becouse this technology is changing and developing extremely fast, then the speakers become obsolete.

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Re: Another idea for a new Harbeth speaker

                          I would vote for an M35. A 3 way priced and sized between the M30 and M40.1. Possibly making it a floor stander.

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Re: Another idea for a new Harbeth speaker

                            Originally posted by Vlado View Post
                            I'm not mentioned intentionaly the DAC, becouse this technology is changing and developing extremely fast, then the speakers become obsolete.
                            Well, the flip side of this argument is that while computers are a fine way to store digital data, they tend not to have the world's greatest analog output stages, which means that some kind of DAC is essential for the best sound, whether it's standalone or built in to the speakers.

                            I'm not an expert, but DACs strike me as being a fairly mature technology at this point - unless there's a radical format change, they're going to be good for the forseeable future. And you don't have to be stuck with it anway - a line level input allows for the use of any new digital technology that might come along.
                            Last edited by EricW; 18-09-2009, 10:31 PM. Reason: clarify

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Re: Another idea for a new Harbeth speaker

                              Originally posted by Ron Herbster View Post
                              I would vote for an M35. A 3 way priced and sized between the M30 and M40.1. Possibly making it a floor stander.
                              Ron: have you seen this thread? http://www.harbeth.co.uk/usergroup/showthread.php?t=580

                              Great minds ...

                              I don't think it should be a floorstander, though - seems not to square with the Harbeth philosophy and design approach.

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X